MTS India is hiring a brand new innovation team, 6-10 people. Looking for unique individuals who are passionate about spearheading innovation projects across the whole company. Junior and senior roles
MTS India is a mobile voice and data service provider.
redsparks is a campaign to find the creative enablers, lateral thinkers and outliers for an Innovation Team. It's the chance of a lifetime! Your decisions can impact the future roadmap of MTS India and change the face of the telecom market in India.
Applications are open now through March 20th on the redsparks Facebook page where you'll also find more information. "Like" the page to stay up-to-date, spread the word to all your friends and get going! To apply, simply click on the "GO" link at the bottom of the Facebook page.
http://www.facebook.com/MTSredsparks
Showing posts with label India. Show all posts
Showing posts with label India. Show all posts
Saturday
Friday
India announces a national innovation fund for early stage capital
News alert
The National Innovation Council has recently addressed 2 major issues in the Indian innovation ecosystem
As always the devil will be in the details. Will the fund have the resources to disburse such a huge sum in hundreds of tiny investments, perhaps evaluating thousands before they find the right ones? Will an infrastructure network be enough to increase collaboration and knowledge sharing between dispersed and competing institutes? We'll see. For now, good things are happening.
The National Innovation Council has recently addressed 2 major issues in the Indian innovation ecosystem
- Within the next 2-3 months a national innovation fund will be set up to provide early stage seed capital for ventures in areas such as health and education. The fund will reportedly have Rs. 1'000 crore (or around $220 mio) to invest.
- The Union Budget for 2011-2012 will cover the creation of a new knowledge network - an optical fiber network that will connect 1500 institutes across India
As always the devil will be in the details. Will the fund have the resources to disburse such a huge sum in hundreds of tiny investments, perhaps evaluating thousands before they find the right ones? Will an infrastructure network be enough to increase collaboration and knowledge sharing between dispersed and competing institutes? We'll see. For now, good things are happening.
Labels:
ecosystem,
India,
innovation,
networks,
policy
Monday
Survey on Indian and Chinese immigrants/returnees
Wadhwa, V., Saxenian, A., Freeman, R. B., & Gereffi, G. (2009). America's Loss is the World's Gain: America's New Immigrant Entrepreneurs, Part 4. Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1348616.
This just landed in my inbox... I've been wondering for a long time where to find numbers on Indians returning to India from the US. There is still no comprehensive data, but Wadhwa et al. have been interviewing Indian and Chinese students and alumni of US universities for several years and put together a decent sample.
The study is skewed towards the most highly educated immigrants/returnees. These are the people most likely to contribute disproportionately to science and technology in the countries where they choose to live.
Here are some highlights:
We find that, though restrictive immigration policies caused some returnees to depart the United States, the most significant factors in the decision to return home were career opportunities, family ties, and quality of life.
Immigration to the US and back to the home country appears to be driven by very similar (though not exactly the same) reasons.
The returnees cited career, education, and quality of life as the main reasons to come to the United States.
- Amongst the strongest factors bringing these immigrants to the U.S. were professional and educational development opportunities. Of Indian and Chinese respondents, 93.5 percent and 91.6 percent respectively said that professional development was an important factor, and 85.9 percent and 90.5 percent respectively said that educational development was important in their decision to migrate to the United States.
- Other key factors were quality-of-life concerns, better infrastructure and facilities, and better compensation. The majority (67.4 percent of Indians and 69.1 percent of Chinese) said that the availability of jobs in their home countries was not a consideration in their decision to migrate to the United States.
Returnees cited career and quality of life as the main reason to return to their home country rather than stay in the United States.
- The commonest professional factor (86.8% of Chinese and 79.0 percent of Indians) motivating workers to return home was the growing demand for their skills in their home countries.
- A significant majority (84.0% of Chinese and 68.7 percent of Indians) believed that
their home countries provided better career opportunities. Furthermore, 87.3 percent of Chinese and 62.3 percent of Indians saw better career opportunities in their home countries than in the United States.
- Financial compensation was a factor important to 62.1 percent of Chinese and 49.2 percent of Indian returnees.
Family considerations are strong magnets pulling immigrants back to their home countries. Care for aging parents was considered by 89.4 percent of Indians and 79.1 percent of Chinese respondents to be much better in their home countries. Family
values were also considered to be better in their home countries by 79.7 percent of Indians and 67.0 percent of Chinese. Additionally, 88.0 percent of Indians and 76.8 percent of Chinese reported that the opportunity to be close to family and friends was better at home.
Indians, in particular, believe that their quality of life is better in India than in the US, and that India provides their children with a better environment in terms of emotional growth and education.
While visa issues were not cited as a main driver of the decision to return home, they were often mentioned as a significant difficulty of settling in the US and exacerbating the distance to family and friends by restricting travel.
Once they are back in their home country, returnees tend to do well, advancing faster in their careers than they would have in the US. They view financial compensation (adjusted for cost of living) and career appreciation as better than in the US. However, they also face significant difficulties from reverse culture shock to infrastructure problems and pollution.
26.4 percent of Chinese and 26.5 percent of Indian returnees indicated that it was highly unlikely that they would return to the US.
This just landed in my inbox... I've been wondering for a long time where to find numbers on Indians returning to India from the US. There is still no comprehensive data, but Wadhwa et al. have been interviewing Indian and Chinese students and alumni of US universities for several years and put together a decent sample.
The study is skewed towards the most highly educated immigrants/returnees. These are the people most likely to contribute disproportionately to science and technology in the countries where they choose to live.
Here are some highlights:
We find that, though restrictive immigration policies caused some returnees to depart the United States, the most significant factors in the decision to return home were career opportunities, family ties, and quality of life.
Immigration to the US and back to the home country appears to be driven by very similar (though not exactly the same) reasons.
The returnees cited career, education, and quality of life as the main reasons to come to the United States.
- Amongst the strongest factors bringing these immigrants to the U.S. were professional and educational development opportunities. Of Indian and Chinese respondents, 93.5 percent and 91.6 percent respectively said that professional development was an important factor, and 85.9 percent and 90.5 percent respectively said that educational development was important in their decision to migrate to the United States.
- Other key factors were quality-of-life concerns, better infrastructure and facilities, and better compensation. The majority (67.4 percent of Indians and 69.1 percent of Chinese) said that the availability of jobs in their home countries was not a consideration in their decision to migrate to the United States.
Returnees cited career and quality of life as the main reason to return to their home country rather than stay in the United States.
- The commonest professional factor (86.8% of Chinese and 79.0 percent of Indians) motivating workers to return home was the growing demand for their skills in their home countries.
- A significant majority (84.0% of Chinese and 68.7 percent of Indians) believed that
their home countries provided better career opportunities. Furthermore, 87.3 percent of Chinese and 62.3 percent of Indians saw better career opportunities in their home countries than in the United States.
- Financial compensation was a factor important to 62.1 percent of Chinese and 49.2 percent of Indian returnees.
Family considerations are strong magnets pulling immigrants back to their home countries. Care for aging parents was considered by 89.4 percent of Indians and 79.1 percent of Chinese respondents to be much better in their home countries. Family
values were also considered to be better in their home countries by 79.7 percent of Indians and 67.0 percent of Chinese. Additionally, 88.0 percent of Indians and 76.8 percent of Chinese reported that the opportunity to be close to family and friends was better at home.
Indians, in particular, believe that their quality of life is better in India than in the US, and that India provides their children with a better environment in terms of emotional growth and education.
While visa issues were not cited as a main driver of the decision to return home, they were often mentioned as a significant difficulty of settling in the US and exacerbating the distance to family and friends by restricting travel.
Once they are back in their home country, returnees tend to do well, advancing faster in their careers than they would have in the US. They view financial compensation (adjusted for cost of living) and career appreciation as better than in the US. However, they also face significant difficulties from reverse culture shock to infrastructure problems and pollution.
26.4 percent of Chinese and 26.5 percent of Indian returnees indicated that it was highly unlikely that they would return to the US.
Labels:
China,
diaspora,
immigration,
India,
networks
Friday
Dissertation abstract
Now that the dissertation draft is complete, I feel it's time to put my abstract online for those people who want a bit more than my "elevator spiel" about what I actually wrote. Find it here thanks to Google Docs.
Labels:
clusters,
collaboration,
geography,
India,
innovation,
networks,
R and D
Monday
Innovation has a long way to go in Bangalore
As the headlines proclaim Bangalore to be the next Silicon Valley, more critical voices are often drowned out. This one will hopefully fare better. NASSCOM and BCG recently published a report on the innovation ecosystem for the Indian IT system. The following graphic from the report basically sums up their conclusions: India has a long, long way to go.

In addition, the authors found that the willingness and initiative of Indian IT firms to invest in firm-level innovation could use a massive increase.
The Indian innovation system has a lot of potential for improvement. Given that the the Bangalore IT cluster developed in response to foreign (not domestic) demand, one could ask whether other elements could also be "imported" into the local innovation system. For example, it appears that much of the more fundamental research in Bangalore's corporate R&D labs is being conducted by US-trained researchers. On the one hand, the knowledge and relationships that these researchers bring with them may help accelerate the development of Bangalore's innovation system. On the other hand, relying on foreign research training is definitely not sustainable.
In addition, the authors found that the willingness and initiative of Indian IT firms to invest in firm-level innovation could use a massive increase.
The Indian innovation system has a lot of potential for improvement. Given that the the Bangalore IT cluster developed in response to foreign (not domestic) demand, one could ask whether other elements could also be "imported" into the local innovation system. For example, it appears that much of the more fundamental research in Bangalore's corporate R&D labs is being conducted by US-trained researchers. On the one hand, the knowledge and relationships that these researchers bring with them may help accelerate the development of Bangalore's innovation system. On the other hand, relying on foreign research training is definitely not sustainable.
Labels:
cities,
clusters,
ecosystem,
India,
innovation,
IT industry
Friday
Argonauts, ethnic scientific communities
AnnaLee Saxenian, The New Argonauts, Harvard University Press, 2006
William Kerr, Ethnic Scientific Communities and International Technology Diffusion, HBS Working Paper 06-022, 2006
Ajay Agrawal, Devesh Kapur, John McHale, Defying Distance: Examining the Influence of the Diaspora on Scientific Knowledge Flows, Working Paper 2004
Entrepreneurial networks carry regional advantage across distance
AnnaLee Saxenian has long been a follower of localized firm and professional networks in the hi-tech industry, highlighting their superiority over corporate hierarchies in her book "Regional Advantage." More recently, in "The New Argonauts," she has turned to ethnic professional networks in Silicon Valley, especially in the Indian, Chinese and Israeli communities. These networks, originally founded for social purposes, evolved to become professional networks for advice, capital and know-how for immigrant entrepreneurs. As immigrant entrepreneurs in Silicon Valley identified business opportunities in their home countries, the networks extended to support these new ventures. They also tied into their home-countries' networks through alumni associations and family ties.
Thus, organizations that were once highly localized began to reach across continents - and their benefits with them. Access to tacit knowledge (technical and managerial), a common understanding of entrepreneurship, shared language and culture have all been considered factors that are bound by geography and contribute to the success of regional economies. Now, they are transcending vast distances thanks to the kinds of networks described by Saxenian. New "Argonauts" (people who work in two or more regions, shuttling back and forth several times per month) literally carry market and technological knowledge, contacts, business models and capital around the world.
As a result:
Silicon Valley, once the uncontested technology leader, is now integrated into a dynamic network of specialized and complementary regional economies.
These new technology regions are not replicas of Silicon Valley, nor are they becoming new Silicon Valleys [...] Even as the returnees seek to use their experience in Silicon Valley to reshape these institutions, distinctive regional and national histories ensure that the identities and technology trajectories of these regions are unlikely to converge.
Some quantitative evidence
Ajay Agrawal, Devesh Kapur and John McHale analyzed patent citations within the Indian diaspora. They found that co-ethnicity increases the likelihood of knowledge flows. Diaspora membership is also found to substitute for co-location as a conduit for knowledge flows.
In a similar study, William Kerr has found quantitative evidence for the power of ethnic networks in a patent citation study. By linking patent data with an ethnic name-database, he was able to analyze ethnic scientific communities in the United States and the communities' home countries. He found that ethnic communities contribute significantly to technology adoption within the first five years of a new technology being developed.
Kerr also found tangible benefits for the home countries using a factor productivity approach: Greater integration with the US technology frontier contributed to an increase in manufacturing output in these countries. In more advanced economies the effect was due to productivity increases; in less advanced countries, productivity increases combined with a reallocation of labor from agriculture to manufacturing.
William Kerr, Ethnic Scientific Communities and International Technology Diffusion, HBS Working Paper 06-022, 2006
Ajay Agrawal, Devesh Kapur, John McHale, Defying Distance: Examining the Influence of the Diaspora on Scientific Knowledge Flows, Working Paper 2004
Entrepreneurial networks carry regional advantage across distance
AnnaLee Saxenian has long been a follower of localized firm and professional networks in the hi-tech industry, highlighting their superiority over corporate hierarchies in her book "Regional Advantage." More recently, in "The New Argonauts," she has turned to ethnic professional networks in Silicon Valley, especially in the Indian, Chinese and Israeli communities. These networks, originally founded for social purposes, evolved to become professional networks for advice, capital and know-how for immigrant entrepreneurs. As immigrant entrepreneurs in Silicon Valley identified business opportunities in their home countries, the networks extended to support these new ventures. They also tied into their home-countries' networks through alumni associations and family ties.
Thus, organizations that were once highly localized began to reach across continents - and their benefits with them. Access to tacit knowledge (technical and managerial), a common understanding of entrepreneurship, shared language and culture have all been considered factors that are bound by geography and contribute to the success of regional economies. Now, they are transcending vast distances thanks to the kinds of networks described by Saxenian. New "Argonauts" (people who work in two or more regions, shuttling back and forth several times per month) literally carry market and technological knowledge, contacts, business models and capital around the world.
As a result:
Silicon Valley, once the uncontested technology leader, is now integrated into a dynamic network of specialized and complementary regional economies.
These new technology regions are not replicas of Silicon Valley, nor are they becoming new Silicon Valleys [...] Even as the returnees seek to use their experience in Silicon Valley to reshape these institutions, distinctive regional and national histories ensure that the identities and technology trajectories of these regions are unlikely to converge.
Some quantitative evidence
Ajay Agrawal, Devesh Kapur and John McHale analyzed patent citations within the Indian diaspora. They found that co-ethnicity increases the likelihood of knowledge flows. Diaspora membership is also found to substitute for co-location as a conduit for knowledge flows.
In a similar study, William Kerr has found quantitative evidence for the power of ethnic networks in a patent citation study. By linking patent data with an ethnic name-database, he was able to analyze ethnic scientific communities in the United States and the communities' home countries. He found that ethnic communities contribute significantly to technology adoption within the first five years of a new technology being developed.
Kerr also found tangible benefits for the home countries using a factor productivity approach: Greater integration with the US technology frontier contributed to an increase in manufacturing output in these countries. In more advanced economies the effect was due to productivity increases; in less advanced countries, productivity increases combined with a reallocation of labor from agriculture to manufacturing.
Monday
National Innovation System timelines: India, China, USA
Found on Yoshiki Mikami's virtual class website.
This is Mikami's overview of the evolution of the Indian national innovation system from the 18th century to the present. The data on more recent decades isn't quite comprehensive, but it's useful to get a timeline.
Mikami's site also has timelines for China and the USA.
This is Mikami's overview of the evolution of the Indian national innovation system from the 18th century to the present. The data on more recent decades isn't quite comprehensive, but it's useful to get a timeline.
Mikami's site also has timelines for China and the USA.
Labels:
China,
economic history,
ecosystem,
India,
innovation
Thursday
Taiwan-India, China-India linkages
Anyone following AnnaLee Saxenian's work is aware of the close connections between the semiconductor industries in Silicon Valley, Taiwan, and - more recently - Shanghai. I have been wondering for a while whether India had the potential to become the next node in this evolving network.
While the semiconductor industry is still quite small in India, there have been some interesting developments. Silicon Valley firms already do some of their chip design work to Bangalore, Hyderabad etc. Plans for Fab City in Hyderabad appear to be firming up after much bickering and speculation. Now, a panel discussion between the Taiwan Semiconductor Industry Association (TSIA) and its Indian counterpart, ISA, is being heralded. It's a small step: TSIA's discussions revolved around partnering with India for chip design and embedded software.
During a panel discussion in STMicroelectronics campus in Greater Noida, between TSIA and the India Semiconductor Association (ISA) on "Opportunities and areas of cooperation between India and Taiwan," TSIA was quite clear that in the absence of an ecosystem and industry infrastructure for setting up manufacturing units, including fabs in India, Taiwanese firms would be ready to tap the IC design and embedded software development skills of Indian engineers for innovating and developing new technologies and products.
"Taiwan is an established manufacturing hub in the semiconductor industry, and we see a great potential to outsource a host of requirements ranging from chip design, testing, packaging and embedded software to developing IPs from our Indian counterparts," said, Paul Chiang, VP, Nanya Technology.
James P. M. Chen, VP, Sales center, Winbond Electronics, a leading Taiwanese semiconductor said his company would be willing to invest in India or collaborate with Indian firms to build a R&D facility as there is no dearth of quality designers in India.
"Voice&Data" seem to have a particular interest in tracking the India-China story...
While the semiconductor industry is still quite small in India, there have been some interesting developments. Silicon Valley firms already do some of their chip design work to Bangalore, Hyderabad etc. Plans for Fab City in Hyderabad appear to be firming up after much bickering and speculation. Now, a panel discussion between the Taiwan Semiconductor Industry Association (TSIA) and its Indian counterpart, ISA, is being heralded. It's a small step: TSIA's discussions revolved around partnering with India for chip design and embedded software.
During a panel discussion in STMicroelectronics campus in Greater Noida, between TSIA and the India Semiconductor Association (ISA) on "Opportunities and areas of cooperation between India and Taiwan," TSIA was quite clear that in the absence of an ecosystem and industry infrastructure for setting up manufacturing units, including fabs in India, Taiwanese firms would be ready to tap the IC design and embedded software development skills of Indian engineers for innovating and developing new technologies and products.
"Taiwan is an established manufacturing hub in the semiconductor industry, and we see a great potential to outsource a host of requirements ranging from chip design, testing, packaging and embedded software to developing IPs from our Indian counterparts," said, Paul Chiang, VP, Nanya Technology.
James P. M. Chen, VP, Sales center, Winbond Electronics, a leading Taiwanese semiconductor said his company would be willing to invest in India or collaborate with Indian firms to build a R&D facility as there is no dearth of quality designers in India.
"Voice&Data" seem to have a particular interest in tracking the India-China story...
Saturday
BCG on R&D in India and China
Boston Consulting Group, Innovation 2006
Over the past year and a half, BCG has published various surveys, reports and “opportunities for action” on research and development in India, China and other rapidly emerging economies. The most interesting data are in the Innovation Survey 2006.
The largest target market for increased R&D spending remains the USA. And Western Europe still comes in second, albeit barely. India and China are rapidly becoming more important. About 45% of respondents said their company planned to increase R&D spending in China; and the same number planned to increase R&D spending in India. This is up from 2005, when only one-third of companies were planning to increase their R&D investments in 'rapidly developing economies.'
China draws increased R&D investments from significantly more consumer product/retail companies than India does. However in every other industry in the survey more or the same number of companies planned to increase their Indian R&D spending (see graph below). This comes as something as a surprise since it suggests stronger R&D growth for India than China. It is important to remember, though that China receives more foreign R&D investments in absolute terms - both FDI dollars and number of labs - and remains the most attractive location for future investments. (See UNCTAD's World Investment Report 2005 ch. 3-4.)

According to BCG's survey, cost – 34% of respondents – and localization (access to local markets) – 32% of respondents – are the main drivers for these investments. Access to R&D talent was mentioned by 21% of respondents.
The Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) found similar drivers in their 2004 study but weighted them differently: Competition for talent, new technologies and easier market access have accelerated the process of R&D globalisation, with countries such as India and China hosting significant volumes of R&D activity for multinationals. Cost is a driver of globalisation too, but its significance can be overplayed as far as R&D goes. ... Speed of development is a more important benefit of the global research economy.
BCG also investigated the type of R&D being conducted in India and China. For anyone who's been watching the R&D space in Bangalore, Beijing and Shanghai it should come as no surprise that most of the investments are D rather than R. The main activity in India and China is product development, followed by product design. However, 15% of respondents said that their increased R&D spending would affect basic research and idea generation.
Conclusions
BCG encourages readers to reconsider the strategies in rapidly developing economies (RDEs), especially in terms of utilizing local talent to conduct more basic research and idea generation in these locations. This is somewhat at odds with the laments of companies that do engage in very high-end research: Development talent is plentiful, but research talent is very hard to find in most industries.
A note on the survey sample: Of the 1'070 respondents to the survey 450 were employed in the US, 71 in India, and 15 in China. The bulk of the rest were from Western economies. I wonder whether this skewed some of the comparative figures on India and China...
Over the past year and a half, BCG has published various surveys, reports and “opportunities for action” on research and development in India, China and other rapidly emerging economies. The most interesting data are in the Innovation Survey 2006.
The largest target market for increased R&D spending remains the USA. And Western Europe still comes in second, albeit barely. India and China are rapidly becoming more important. About 45% of respondents said their company planned to increase R&D spending in China; and the same number planned to increase R&D spending in India. This is up from 2005, when only one-third of companies were planning to increase their R&D investments in 'rapidly developing economies.'
China draws increased R&D investments from significantly more consumer product/retail companies than India does. However in every other industry in the survey more or the same number of companies planned to increase their Indian R&D spending (see graph below). This comes as something as a surprise since it suggests stronger R&D growth for India than China. It is important to remember, though that China receives more foreign R&D investments in absolute terms - both FDI dollars and number of labs - and remains the most attractive location for future investments. (See UNCTAD's World Investment Report 2005 ch. 3-4.)

According to BCG's survey, cost – 34% of respondents – and localization (access to local markets) – 32% of respondents – are the main drivers for these investments. Access to R&D talent was mentioned by 21% of respondents.
The Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) found similar drivers in their 2004 study but weighted them differently: Competition for talent, new technologies and easier market access have accelerated the process of R&D globalisation, with countries such as India and China hosting significant volumes of R&D activity for multinationals. Cost is a driver of globalisation too, but its significance can be overplayed as far as R&D goes. ... Speed of development is a more important benefit of the global research economy.
BCG also investigated the type of R&D being conducted in India and China. For anyone who's been watching the R&D space in Bangalore, Beijing and Shanghai it should come as no surprise that most of the investments are D rather than R. The main activity in India and China is product development, followed by product design. However, 15% of respondents said that their increased R&D spending would affect basic research and idea generation.
ConclusionsBCG encourages readers to reconsider the strategies in rapidly developing economies (RDEs), especially in terms of utilizing local talent to conduct more basic research and idea generation in these locations. This is somewhat at odds with the laments of companies that do engage in very high-end research: Development talent is plentiful, but research talent is very hard to find in most industries.
A note on the survey sample: Of the 1'070 respondents to the survey 450 were employed in the US, 71 in India, and 15 in China. The bulk of the rest were from Western economies. I wonder whether this skewed some of the comparative figures on India and China...
Labels:
China,
data sources,
India,
R and D
Thursday
The role of Bangalore's returnees
Migration of highly skilled Indian: Case studies of IT and health professionals, STI Working Paper 2004/6, Binod Khadria
Currently, there is a sense that foreign investment into R&D in India is closely linked to Indians who were educated and/or worked abroad and are returning home (returnees). Key positions are often filled with returnees or expatriates, and many team leaders and individual investigators are also returnees. Understanding the importance and role of returnees is essential to assessing the growth potential of India as a destination for R&D investment.
Unfortunately, research on this phenomenon is sparse. One of the few sources I have found is Binod Khadria's recent case study IT professionals for the OECD Directorate for Science, Technology and Industry.
The study is based on 45 interviews with IT professionals (only 4 of whom have PhDs) who returned to India after a stint abroad. Unfortunately, that rules out statistical significance in the study. Also, no mention is made of respondents' current occupation. Nevertheless the case study points to some useful ideas.
To me, one of the most interesting aspects of the study was the fact that over a third of respondents had stayed in their host country for less than 2 years. Also, almost half of the respondents said that their employer was the motivating factor for their trip abroad. Although Khadria doesn't provide cross-tables, I expect that these two categories are highly correlated. Khadria does mention that "projects" are an important factor in out-migration.
The question is whether someone who was sent by an India-based employer to the US on a limited project is a returnee in the same sense as someone who emigrated to the US and worked or completed their studies there independently. I would expect that the two experiences were quite different, and that the second group had greater exposure to US culture and networks. Upon their return they might play similar roles in terms of "socializing" their colleagues into global business practices, but their role in providing access to US/global clients, professional networks etc. would probably be much more limited.
On the other hand, these categories may just be an artefact of different generations' experiences. 20 years ago, most emigrants would have left India to settle elsewhere for good. Today, there are more opportunities for people to move in and out of the country, pursuing more fluid careers (a point made by Rupa Chanda).
More results
Difficulties/problems after returning from abroad: culture of professionalism
When asked about the difficulties and problems in adjusting to the present working conditions in Bangalore, as many as 32 respondents explicitly exressed that they did not face any major hurdle in adjusting to their present working organisational climate. The background of respondents and their earlier exposure to India and its culture helped them a lot in adjusting back in Bangalore after their return from abroad. [...] 13 respondents mentioned some problems [...] The major adjustment problems faced by them were caused due to the lethargic administrative procedures, inefficient handling of the day-to-day professional concerns, relatively unhealthy business ethics, poor research facilities (especially in academics) and poor work culture.
Value of overseas experience: socialization, absorptive capacity, prestige
When reacting to the question, 'which of the following do you consider the most important to your current work/business in Bangalore', thirty-seven respondents accepted that the 'knowledge and skills gained overseas through higher education and on-the-job training' is highly useful for their current jobs in Bangalore. Two-thirds of the respondents expressed that the opportunity to work abroad helped equip themselves with the recent and most appropriate technologies. Only nine respondents recognised the 'role of professional networks established overseas' in their current jobs in Bangalore. The asserted that these networks helped them in providing information on several professional issues like technology, management, outsourcing, etc. Only three respondents recognised the importance of '(financial) capital accumulated overseas' in their current occupation in Bangalore.
All the respondents except one acknoledged the 'contribution of skills, experience, knowledge and ideas' which they have gained while working abroad, in their present employment/business in Bangalore. A majority of them have elaborated that their experience helps them a lot while interacting with the clients, technological innovations and coping with the rapid technological changes, improving management practices, and, above all, confidence building. Respondents from the academic world considered that it is the exposure to different work cultures and a sound academic base, which is of paramount importance and very useful in their current positions. [...] it has been expressed by almost all the respondents that their experiences abroad are well recognised and valued by their employers and by their colleagues as well. The receive more attention from their superiors and colleagues, who 'listen to them carefully on important matters'.
Currently, there is a sense that foreign investment into R&D in India is closely linked to Indians who were educated and/or worked abroad and are returning home (returnees). Key positions are often filled with returnees or expatriates, and many team leaders and individual investigators are also returnees. Understanding the importance and role of returnees is essential to assessing the growth potential of India as a destination for R&D investment.
Unfortunately, research on this phenomenon is sparse. One of the few sources I have found is Binod Khadria's recent case study IT professionals for the OECD Directorate for Science, Technology and Industry.
The study is based on 45 interviews with IT professionals (only 4 of whom have PhDs) who returned to India after a stint abroad. Unfortunately, that rules out statistical significance in the study. Also, no mention is made of respondents' current occupation. Nevertheless the case study points to some useful ideas.
To me, one of the most interesting aspects of the study was the fact that over a third of respondents had stayed in their host country for less than 2 years. Also, almost half of the respondents said that their employer was the motivating factor for their trip abroad. Although Khadria doesn't provide cross-tables, I expect that these two categories are highly correlated. Khadria does mention that "projects" are an important factor in out-migration.
The question is whether someone who was sent by an India-based employer to the US on a limited project is a returnee in the same sense as someone who emigrated to the US and worked or completed their studies there independently. I would expect that the two experiences were quite different, and that the second group had greater exposure to US culture and networks. Upon their return they might play similar roles in terms of "socializing" their colleagues into global business practices, but their role in providing access to US/global clients, professional networks etc. would probably be much more limited.
On the other hand, these categories may just be an artefact of different generations' experiences. 20 years ago, most emigrants would have left India to settle elsewhere for good. Today, there are more opportunities for people to move in and out of the country, pursuing more fluid careers (a point made by Rupa Chanda).
More results
Difficulties/problems after returning from abroad: culture of professionalism
When asked about the difficulties and problems in adjusting to the present working conditions in Bangalore, as many as 32 respondents explicitly exressed that they did not face any major hurdle in adjusting to their present working organisational climate. The background of respondents and their earlier exposure to India and its culture helped them a lot in adjusting back in Bangalore after their return from abroad. [...] 13 respondents mentioned some problems [...] The major adjustment problems faced by them were caused due to the lethargic administrative procedures, inefficient handling of the day-to-day professional concerns, relatively unhealthy business ethics, poor research facilities (especially in academics) and poor work culture.
Value of overseas experience: socialization, absorptive capacity, prestige
When reacting to the question, 'which of the following do you consider the most important to your current work/business in Bangalore', thirty-seven respondents accepted that the 'knowledge and skills gained overseas through higher education and on-the-job training' is highly useful for their current jobs in Bangalore. Two-thirds of the respondents expressed that the opportunity to work abroad helped equip themselves with the recent and most appropriate technologies. Only nine respondents recognised the 'role of professional networks established overseas' in their current jobs in Bangalore. The asserted that these networks helped them in providing information on several professional issues like technology, management, outsourcing, etc. Only three respondents recognised the importance of '(financial) capital accumulated overseas' in their current occupation in Bangalore.
All the respondents except one acknoledged the 'contribution of skills, experience, knowledge and ideas' which they have gained while working abroad, in their present employment/business in Bangalore. A majority of them have elaborated that their experience helps them a lot while interacting with the clients, technological innovations and coping with the rapid technological changes, improving management practices, and, above all, confidence building. Respondents from the academic world considered that it is the exposure to different work cultures and a sound academic base, which is of paramount importance and very useful in their current positions. [...] it has been expressed by almost all the respondents that their experiences abroad are well recognised and valued by their employers and by their colleagues as well. The receive more attention from their superiors and colleagues, who 'listen to them carefully on important matters'.
Labels:
diaspora,
India,
IT industry,
migration
Tuesday
R&D in China and India: Great image, few reliable numbers
I’ve been working on a round-up of Indian and Chinese R&D statistics. The first thing that caught my attention was that (foreign) R&D in China seemed to be getting much more scholarly attention than Indian R&D.
A quick Google search provides some backup for this hunch. Searching Google Scholar for <India “R&D”> returns 21’600 hits. A search for <China “R&D”> returns 32’200 hits. Of course, there may be all kinds of junk in those hits, but a factor of 1.5 does show some difference. Another back of the envelope technique I used was to search for India and China in the journal “R&D management.” Searching for India returned 30 citations; searching for China returned 44. (Again, this needs to be taken cautiously since most of the differential is due to a special issue on R&D management in China).
On the other hand, in regular (business) news, the two countries are about even. The same Google searches as above in Google News returned 1’130 hits for India and 1’110 for China today.
Further searching showed that it’s quite difficult to put together a rough and ready overview of R&D statistics for India from the comfort of your desk. Few numbers are available online, and various databases contradict each other. (For example, the reported number of engineering and technology doctorates awarded in 1989 varies from 238 to 586, depending on the source.) The most useful numbers (for an outside investor) are provided by the software industry association, NASSCOM – and even these are meager and purely industry focused.
China, on the other hand, publishes a handy bunch of figures on the website of the Ministry of Science and Technology. Of course, Chinese government statistics are notoriously unreliable; but at least they appear to publish a uniform set of numbers and provide easy access to them.
The point here is less one of scholarly research than of marketing. India and China are competing for foreign R&D dollars (and spillovers). To do this, they need to demonstrate the availability of research talent. Conversations I have had, suggest that neither country is building its R&D strength on available resources. In both countries (though more so in China), proximity to a huge customer base is an important reason for firms to conduct R&D there. Lower costs also help. Both benefit from the West’s realization that India and China have very large college-educated populations.
However, “college-educated” does not equal “research-trained.” Several MNC labs have found that only a handful of elite schools provide the same kind of research training as they expect from researchers elsewhere in the world. As I heard time and again, development talent is plentiful; the research talent pool is very small.
Given a less than ideal labor pool, how do Bangalore and Beijing achieve their status of Asia’s R&D hubs? How can they expect to outperform Japan in terms of research?
China’s strategy has apparently been to muscle its way into the field by requiring foreign firms to set up labs if they wish to get permits for their low-cost factories – and by investing heavily in state-of-the-art infrastructure.
Bangalore seems to be benefiting from a halo effect: As the go-to spot for software development it becomes a natural location for IT research as well. In both countries, the case has also been made that returnees play a crucial role. As more interesting jobs open up (e.g. team leader in an R&D lab), more highly qualified emigrants find it worth their while to return home. Of course, more opportunities and market demand will eventually also have an effect on research training – whether in universities or in industry.
In the end, excellence in a field may translate into R&D prowess. And an image as an R&D hub may help sustain the current boom long enough for an adequate talent pool to develop. Until we have reliable numbers, though, nobody will be able to tell for sure.
A quick Google search provides some backup for this hunch. Searching Google Scholar for <India “R&D”> returns 21’600 hits. A search for <China “R&D”> returns 32’200 hits. Of course, there may be all kinds of junk in those hits, but a factor of 1.5 does show some difference. Another back of the envelope technique I used was to search for India and China in the journal “R&D management.” Searching for India returned 30 citations; searching for China returned 44. (Again, this needs to be taken cautiously since most of the differential is due to a special issue on R&D management in China).
On the other hand, in regular (business) news, the two countries are about even. The same Google searches as above in Google News returned 1’130 hits for India and 1’110 for China today.
Further searching showed that it’s quite difficult to put together a rough and ready overview of R&D statistics for India from the comfort of your desk. Few numbers are available online, and various databases contradict each other. (For example, the reported number of engineering and technology doctorates awarded in 1989 varies from 238 to 586, depending on the source.) The most useful numbers (for an outside investor) are provided by the software industry association, NASSCOM – and even these are meager and purely industry focused.
China, on the other hand, publishes a handy bunch of figures on the website of the Ministry of Science and Technology. Of course, Chinese government statistics are notoriously unreliable; but at least they appear to publish a uniform set of numbers and provide easy access to them.
The point here is less one of scholarly research than of marketing. India and China are competing for foreign R&D dollars (and spillovers). To do this, they need to demonstrate the availability of research talent. Conversations I have had, suggest that neither country is building its R&D strength on available resources. In both countries (though more so in China), proximity to a huge customer base is an important reason for firms to conduct R&D there. Lower costs also help. Both benefit from the West’s realization that India and China have very large college-educated populations.
However, “college-educated” does not equal “research-trained.” Several MNC labs have found that only a handful of elite schools provide the same kind of research training as they expect from researchers elsewhere in the world. As I heard time and again, development talent is plentiful; the research talent pool is very small.
Given a less than ideal labor pool, how do Bangalore and Beijing achieve their status of Asia’s R&D hubs? How can they expect to outperform Japan in terms of research?
China’s strategy has apparently been to muscle its way into the field by requiring foreign firms to set up labs if they wish to get permits for their low-cost factories – and by investing heavily in state-of-the-art infrastructure.
Bangalore seems to be benefiting from a halo effect: As the go-to spot for software development it becomes a natural location for IT research as well. In both countries, the case has also been made that returnees play a crucial role. As more interesting jobs open up (e.g. team leader in an R&D lab), more highly qualified emigrants find it worth their while to return home. Of course, more opportunities and market demand will eventually also have an effect on research training – whether in universities or in industry.
In the end, excellence in a field may translate into R&D prowess. And an image as an R&D hub may help sustain the current boom long enough for an adequate talent pool to develop. Until we have reliable numbers, though, nobody will be able to tell for sure.
Labels:
China,
data sources,
India,
R and D
Monday
Saxenian on Bangalore, 5 years ago
Back to India: Indian software engineers are returning with enthusiasm and etrepreneurial know-how, Saxenian, WSJ January 24, 2000
The Bangalore boom: From brain drain to brain circulation? Saxenian. In Bridging the digital divide: Lessons from India, Kenniston and Kumar (eds.), 2000, National Institute of Advanced Studies, Bangalore.
Bangalore: The Silicon Valley of Asia? Saxenian, Conference on Indian economic prospects: Advancing policy reform, Center for Research on Economic Development and Policy Reform, Stanford, May 2000
In 1999 and 2000 AnnaLee Saxenian wrote a series of papers and articles (1, 2, 3) about Bangalore's prospects of becoming the Asia's "Silicon Valley." She drew heavily on her research of Taiwan and the Hsin-Chu hardware cluster in the analysis. Reading these pieces is an interesting look back in time - and useful for putting the current hype in perspective.
At the time India seemed successful in - but limited to - its role as a source of cheap, reliable and routing software coding. To her surprise, Saxenian found that increasing numbers Indian entrepreneurs in Silicon Valley were starting businesses in Bangalore and elsewhere in India. Given the importance of Taiwanese Silicon Valley entrepreneurs for Hsin-Chu's success, she saw this as a hopeful sign for Bangalore. Returnees were bringing angel/venture capital, business models and knowledge of (U.S.) customers with them, along with a willingness to take risks. The government of Karnataka seemed intent on supporting the growing IT industry. All this contributed to a new-found hope in India's IT potential.
However, there were enormous obstacles still to overcome. The bureaucracy and red tape were overwhelming despite the goverment's efforts to help - or at least stay out of the way. Physical infrastructure remained a huge problem. Many Silicon Valley Indians stayed in Bangalore long enough to set up their companies facilities, but then moved back to the U.S. As a result, there was no group comparable to the 'argonauts' (Taiwanese who shuttled between Hsin-Chu and the Valley several times a month) that Saxenian considered crucial Hsin-Chu's success. In addition, many of these new facilities felt more like Silicon Valley outposts than like Bangalorean service centers; most of the people linking India and Silicon Valley were a part of large, international firms, rather than independent entrepreneurs. This severely limited the potential for knowledge spill-overs, both technical and organizational. In 2000, the software industry was still dominated by the "big three" Indian firms (Infosys, Wipro, TCS) and smaller, specialized firms had yet to develop in significant numbers, heavily skewing the size distribution of firms. So, while the anchor firms (both Indian and foreign) were well-developed, the mix of large and small firms typical of successful clusters hadn't emerged.
In the end, Saxenian felt that the ingredients for Bangalore's success were not yet in place, but that the potential was increasing. It would need to develop quickly since Bangalore was already experiencing wage inflation and could no longer compete solely on cost. Competitive pressures were forcing it to move up the value-chain.
In short, there is a small but growing technical community linking India and Silicon Valley - one that could play an important role in upgrading the Indian software industry in the future.
In Saxenian's opinion, Bangalore's best bet was to focus on the domestic market - as a driver for innovation, entrepreneurship, market scale, and knowledge networks. The industry would thus develop a broader base as various firms specialized in different niches. It would also grow enough to allow more specialization (another important factor in cluster development).
Finally, Saxenian pointed out that IT was a success story that should inspire other industries - it would never be able to serve as India's main development strategy.
Many of these points remain valid today, even though there have been some important changes. The emergence of various speicalized, smaller firms (e.g. in biotech and bio-informatics) has gone some way towards balancing the mix of firm-sizes and introducing variety. Bangalore's success in attracting R&D labs and R&D outsourcing is letting it move up the value chain and increase the scope of technological expertise. The amount of venture capital is also growing rapidly and set to increase even more.
The Bangalore boom: From brain drain to brain circulation? Saxenian. In Bridging the digital divide: Lessons from India, Kenniston and Kumar (eds.), 2000, National Institute of Advanced Studies, Bangalore.
Bangalore: The Silicon Valley of Asia? Saxenian, Conference on Indian economic prospects: Advancing policy reform, Center for Research on Economic Development and Policy Reform, Stanford, May 2000
In 1999 and 2000 AnnaLee Saxenian wrote a series of papers and articles (1, 2, 3) about Bangalore's prospects of becoming the Asia's "Silicon Valley." She drew heavily on her research of Taiwan and the Hsin-Chu hardware cluster in the analysis. Reading these pieces is an interesting look back in time - and useful for putting the current hype in perspective.
At the time India seemed successful in - but limited to - its role as a source of cheap, reliable and routing software coding. To her surprise, Saxenian found that increasing numbers Indian entrepreneurs in Silicon Valley were starting businesses in Bangalore and elsewhere in India. Given the importance of Taiwanese Silicon Valley entrepreneurs for Hsin-Chu's success, she saw this as a hopeful sign for Bangalore. Returnees were bringing angel/venture capital, business models and knowledge of (U.S.) customers with them, along with a willingness to take risks. The government of Karnataka seemed intent on supporting the growing IT industry. All this contributed to a new-found hope in India's IT potential.
However, there were enormous obstacles still to overcome. The bureaucracy and red tape were overwhelming despite the goverment's efforts to help - or at least stay out of the way. Physical infrastructure remained a huge problem. Many Silicon Valley Indians stayed in Bangalore long enough to set up their companies facilities, but then moved back to the U.S. As a result, there was no group comparable to the 'argonauts' (Taiwanese who shuttled between Hsin-Chu and the Valley several times a month) that Saxenian considered crucial Hsin-Chu's success. In addition, many of these new facilities felt more like Silicon Valley outposts than like Bangalorean service centers; most of the people linking India and Silicon Valley were a part of large, international firms, rather than independent entrepreneurs. This severely limited the potential for knowledge spill-overs, both technical and organizational. In 2000, the software industry was still dominated by the "big three" Indian firms (Infosys, Wipro, TCS) and smaller, specialized firms had yet to develop in significant numbers, heavily skewing the size distribution of firms. So, while the anchor firms (both Indian and foreign) were well-developed, the mix of large and small firms typical of successful clusters hadn't emerged.
In the end, Saxenian felt that the ingredients for Bangalore's success were not yet in place, but that the potential was increasing. It would need to develop quickly since Bangalore was already experiencing wage inflation and could no longer compete solely on cost. Competitive pressures were forcing it to move up the value-chain.
In short, there is a small but growing technical community linking India and Silicon Valley - one that could play an important role in upgrading the Indian software industry in the future.
In Saxenian's opinion, Bangalore's best bet was to focus on the domestic market - as a driver for innovation, entrepreneurship, market scale, and knowledge networks. The industry would thus develop a broader base as various firms specialized in different niches. It would also grow enough to allow more specialization (another important factor in cluster development).
Finally, Saxenian pointed out that IT was a success story that should inspire other industries - it would never be able to serve as India's main development strategy.
Many of these points remain valid today, even though there have been some important changes. The emergence of various speicalized, smaller firms (e.g. in biotech and bio-informatics) has gone some way towards balancing the mix of firm-sizes and introducing variety. Bangalore's success in attracting R&D labs and R&D outsourcing is letting it move up the value chain and increase the scope of technological expertise. The amount of venture capital is also growing rapidly and set to increase even more.
Labels:
diaspora,
entrepreneurship,
India,
IT industry,
migration
Biotech/bioinformatics India overview
www.biospectrumindia.com
I just finished scanning a year's worth of BioSpectrum issues. Here's a quick overview (with a severe bias towards bioinformatics). For facts and figures, the magazine's BioData is a good resource.
India isn't among the big players yet in terms of biotech, though it does seem to be positioning itself for a leading role in bioinformatics thanks to its strong IT sector. Nevertheless, there is much excitement about biotech taking off, founded not just on euphoria, but on the availability of natural resources (diverse gene pool and ecosystems) and scientific talent, a pharma sector that is moving from manufacturing generic drugs to drug discovery and providing services (e.g. contract research), a large domestic market for bioagri and traditional medicinal knowledge that provides a unique starting point for drug discovery. Of course there is also the cost advantage of conducting biotech in India rather than the United States.
So far vaccines seems to be the single largest biotech business, including exports (mainly WHO-driven) and development of new vaccines. Bioinformatics is a small business by comparison (one tenth the revenues of vaccines in 2002/2003), but the quickest growing one. However, given that the global market is smaller to begin with and that India is entering the market with proven IT competencies, chances are good for status as a global player. Analysts expect India to capture 5% of the global market by 2005. Another sector that relies on India's established reputation as a global player for ITES (IT enabled services) is the market for contract research opportunities (CRO).
In its early stages, bioinformatics was largely a software services business based on supplying custom-made code for foreign pharma and biotech firms. Increasingly, however, Indian bioinformatics firms are launching proprietary products. A growing niche could be internet applications: 'In contrast to the accelerated growth that the internet has experienced, companies in the biotech sector have just begun to utilize the variety of internet applications available. Although maintaining a web presence and accessibility to research exists for these companies, the industry has relatively overlooked the possibilities of B2B commerce, ASP applications or the ubiquitous wireless domain,' says Aditya M Reddy, CEO of Hyderabad-based DeUS Infotech Private Ltd.
So far the main customer base (80% of data-driven drug discovery) is in the US, and to a small extent in Europe, Australia, Singapore and Japan. The domestic pharma and biotech industries are considered by many to be too young to represent a significant market yet.
Despite this, and Ernst & Young survey showed only 3 Indian cross-border alliances in biotech for 2002.
Industry insiders warn that the service business in biotech is limited and that, for India the real money is in discovering new drugs for ourselves and not in supplying information and data to foreign companies, who would then use this information to discover new molecules.
Various clusters are aggressively marketing their locations, e.g. Hyderabad (Genome Valley) and Bangalore (the biotech city).
The main bioinformatics players are Strand Genomics, CDC Linex, Bigtec, Institute of Bioinformatics, Jubilant Biosys, Ocimum Biosolutions, Mascon Life Sciences, Bilcare, Scinova, SysArris, Molecular Connections, and SERC.
The major software outsourcing companies, such as Infosys, Wipro Health Sciences (or Wipro Healthcare), TCS, Kshema Technologies, and Satyam Computer Services are also exploring opportunities. However, their strength seems to lie in providing management software for biotech and pharma companies (bio-IT), rather than specialized bioinformatics.
International players (in bioinformatics and bio-IT) are IBM/IBM India, Intel, Sun Microsystems, Oracle, and Cognizant Technologies.
I just finished scanning a year's worth of BioSpectrum issues. Here's a quick overview (with a severe bias towards bioinformatics). For facts and figures, the magazine's BioData is a good resource.
India isn't among the big players yet in terms of biotech, though it does seem to be positioning itself for a leading role in bioinformatics thanks to its strong IT sector. Nevertheless, there is much excitement about biotech taking off, founded not just on euphoria, but on the availability of natural resources (diverse gene pool and ecosystems) and scientific talent, a pharma sector that is moving from manufacturing generic drugs to drug discovery and providing services (e.g. contract research), a large domestic market for bioagri and traditional medicinal knowledge that provides a unique starting point for drug discovery. Of course there is also the cost advantage of conducting biotech in India rather than the United States.
So far vaccines seems to be the single largest biotech business, including exports (mainly WHO-driven) and development of new vaccines. Bioinformatics is a small business by comparison (one tenth the revenues of vaccines in 2002/2003), but the quickest growing one. However, given that the global market is smaller to begin with and that India is entering the market with proven IT competencies, chances are good for status as a global player. Analysts expect India to capture 5% of the global market by 2005. Another sector that relies on India's established reputation as a global player for ITES (IT enabled services) is the market for contract research opportunities (CRO).
In its early stages, bioinformatics was largely a software services business based on supplying custom-made code for foreign pharma and biotech firms. Increasingly, however, Indian bioinformatics firms are launching proprietary products. A growing niche could be internet applications: 'In contrast to the accelerated growth that the internet has experienced, companies in the biotech sector have just begun to utilize the variety of internet applications available. Although maintaining a web presence and accessibility to research exists for these companies, the industry has relatively overlooked the possibilities of B2B commerce, ASP applications or the ubiquitous wireless domain,' says Aditya M Reddy, CEO of Hyderabad-based DeUS Infotech Private Ltd.
So far the main customer base (80% of data-driven drug discovery) is in the US, and to a small extent in Europe, Australia, Singapore and Japan. The domestic pharma and biotech industries are considered by many to be too young to represent a significant market yet.
Despite this, and Ernst & Young survey showed only 3 Indian cross-border alliances in biotech for 2002.
Industry insiders warn that the service business in biotech is limited and that, for India the real money is in discovering new drugs for ourselves and not in supplying information and data to foreign companies, who would then use this information to discover new molecules.
Various clusters are aggressively marketing their locations, e.g. Hyderabad (Genome Valley) and Bangalore (the biotech city).
The main bioinformatics players are Strand Genomics, CDC Linex, Bigtec, Institute of Bioinformatics, Jubilant Biosys, Ocimum Biosolutions, Mascon Life Sciences, Bilcare, Scinova, SysArris, Molecular Connections, and SERC.
The major software outsourcing companies, such as Infosys, Wipro Health Sciences (or Wipro Healthcare), TCS, Kshema Technologies, and Satyam Computer Services are also exploring opportunities. However, their strength seems to lie in providing management software for biotech and pharma companies (bio-IT), rather than specialized bioinformatics.
International players (in bioinformatics and bio-IT) are IBM/IBM India, Intel, Sun Microsystems, Oracle, and Cognizant Technologies.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)