Showing posts with label cities. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cities. Show all posts

Saturday

Which population matters? Daytime or night time?

Another excellent post from Atlantic Cities.

Which population matters to planners, businesses and service providers? The number of inhabitants only captures part of the picture. New maps capture commuter data to show how cities grow or shrink during the day as people commute in or out for work. For example, Manhattan's population of about 1.5 million doubles to around 3 million every day.

As Emily Badger explains it:
If Manhattan ever needs to evacuate by day during a disaster, the city has to figure out what to do with all 3 million of those people. The city's transportation planners are responsible for every one of them, whether they live in New York or not. And anyone who does business in a service industry on the island – from lunch counters to dry cleaners to department stores – cares a lot more about how many people pass through during the day than who passes out in Manhattan at night. [...] This geography of how populations move on a daily basis should also tell us something about the importance of regional transportation infrastructure. If your city swells in size every day by 50,000 people or more, do you want all of them coming by car?



Wednesday

The Atlantic's Best CityReads of 2012

One of my favorite sources for new cities research, The Atlantic Cities, has a best of 2012 list. From tickles to must-reads...

...starting with their title photo (courtesy of Reuters/China Daily).



Tuesday

Visualizations

Geographic data almost always makes more sense when it's visualized. But good examples are hard to find (probably because they're hard to make...).

Flowing Data pointed me to a particularly cool interactive map that shows the world's current and planned submarine cables. The blog collects data visualization of just about everything from serious to simply fun.

But my favorite one has to be this: a map that shows how large a city would be if the entire population of the world lived in it - by density of different cities.



There's also a book: Visualize This: The FlowingData Guide to Design, Visualization, and Statistics

China: Green cities don't have to come at the expense of economic growth

"How green are China's cities?" McKinsey Quarterly, January 2011.

In connection with the World Economic Forum's themes, McKinsey has published the results of a new study on the sustainability of China's cities. Unsurprisingly, they found huge differences between individual cities.

What may come as a surprise though, is that there was no causal link between sustainability and economic growth. Almost a third of the cities studied were "sustainable growers." They expanded economically while improving on sustainability measures. McKinsey found many "all-round" high performers, suggesting that good city management is key to success, and may even be more influential than potential trade-offs between growth and greening.

Monday

The size of cities

2 recent NYT columns about the size of cities caught my eye.

Edward Glaeser explains why India's (and emerging economies') cities grow so large. And Steven Strogatz explains the power law that describes the exponential distribution of city sizes within a country - and relates it to similar distributions observed within living organisms.

Here's a particularly interesting insight from Strogatz's column:

For instance, if one city is 10 times as populous as another one, does it need 10 times as many gas stations? No. Bigger cities have more gas stations than smaller ones (of course), but not nearly in direct proportion to their size. The number of gas stations grows only in proportion to the 0.77 power of population. The crucial thing is that 0.77 is less than 1. This implies that the bigger a city is, the fewer gas stations it has per person. Put simply, bigger cities enjoy economies of scale. In this sense, bigger is greener.


The same pattern holds for other measures of infrastructure. Whether you measure miles of roadway or length of electrical cables, you find that all of these also decrease, per person, as city size increases. And all show an exponent between 0.7 and 0.9.

Innovation has a long way to go in Bangalore

As the headlines proclaim Bangalore to be the next Silicon Valley, more critical voices are often drowned out. This one will hopefully fare better. NASSCOM and BCG recently published a report on the innovation ecosystem for the Indian IT system. The following graphic from the report basically sums up their conclusions: India has a long, long way to go.



In addition, the authors found that the willingness and initiative of Indian IT firms to invest in firm-level innovation could use a massive increase.

The Indian innovation system has a lot of potential for improvement. Given that the the Bangalore IT cluster developed in response to foreign (not domestic) demand, one could ask whether other elements could also be "imported" into the local innovation system. For example, it appears that much of the more fundamental research in Bangalore's corporate R&D labs is being conducted by US-trained researchers. On the one hand, the knowledge and relationships that these researchers bring with them may help accelerate the development of Bangalore's innovation system. On the other hand, relying on foreign research training is definitely not sustainable.

Tuesday

The locus of globalization

Global networks - Linked cities (Introduction), Saskia Sassen, 2002

Saskia Sassen has been following global capital markets for years. In the introduction of this edited volume, she uses capital markets to explain the strange relationship between economic globalization and geography. While Sassen focuses on global cities (New York, London, Hong Kong, Tokyo, and more recently Sao Paolo, Mexico City, Johannesburg, Bombay, Shanghai, etc.), many of her insights are applicable to specialized clusters. Since much of her analysis is based on the finance industry, the leap to apply it to other information-based industries is not very large. Of course, her aim is a different one than mine. In the larger argument on globalization, financial markets are probably a better indicator of the global economy than the new technologies I'm looking at.

By analogy, her comments on the relationships between global cities is also much-welcome support for my proposition that we are seeing a network of cooperating and competing hi-tech clusters emerge. As Sassen sees it, such a network of global cities already exists.

There is a growing number of transnational actors: not only MNCs, but also NGOs, government regulators, professional associations, mayors etc. As the nation state loses power (e.g. by giving up state monopolies), other geographic entities gain: cities, regions, cross-border regions, and supranational entities (e.g. the EU). Add to this the existence of new 'virtual spaces' and the picture can easily become confusing. On the one hand, cities and regional economies are becoming more important, agglomeration economies are increasingly powerful. On the other hand, ICTs allow a dispersion of information, capital, and thereby business. According to Sassen, these two trends are not wholly contradictory, and 'global cities' are the links between national economies and global circuits.

Cities provide the pronounced territorial concentrations of resources necessary for the management and servicing of more dispersed and mobile resources. By doing so, they reinforce the global influence and the global links of their respective cities - strengthen their position in the global economy. While they therefore remain dependent on their surrounding regions, these cities become a part of the global center: the network of global cities.

The geography of globalization contains dynamics of both dispersal and centralization. The massive trends toward the spatial dispersal of economic activities at the metropolitan, national, and global levels that we associate with globalization have contributed to a demand for new forms of territorial centralization of top-level management and control functions. Insofar as these functions benefit from agglomeration economies even in the face of telematic integration of a firm's globally dispersed manufacturing and service operations, they tend to locate in cities. An important reason why they might benefit from agglomeration economies lies in the presence of business networks.

By central functions I do not only mean headquarters functions; I am referring to all the top-level functions necessary to run a corporate organization operating in multiple countries. These central functions are partly embedded in headquarters, but also in good part in what has been called the corporate services complex, that is, the network of financial, legal, accounting, and advertising firms that handle the complexities of operating in more than one national legal system, national accounting system, advertising culture, and so forth and do so under conditions of rapid innovations in all these fields. Such services have become so specialized and complex that headquarters increasingly buy them from specialized firms rather than produce them in-house. These agglomerations of firms producing central functions for the management and coordination of global economic systems are disproportionately concentrated in an expanding network of global cities. This network represents a strategic factor in the organization of the global economy.

Further, leading firms in information industries require a vast physical infrastructure containing strategic nodes with hyperconcentration of facilities; we need to distinguish between the capacity for global transmission/communication and the material conditions that make this possible.


Sassen goes on to explore the new economic geography that combines agglomerations and global dispersal.

This type of analysis of globalization, which seeks to map the strategic sites with hyperconcentration of resources as well as the cross-border networks that link these sites and others, helps us understand to what extent there is a specific geography of globalization and the fact that it is not a planetary event encompassing all of the world. It is, furthermore, a changing geography, one that has undergone multiple, often specialized transformations over the last few centuries and over the last two decades, and most recently has come to include electronic space.

Today, partly as a result of the new technologies, the spatial correlates of the center can assume several geographic forms, ranging from the CBD (central business district) to a new global grid of cities. Simplifying one could identify three forms of centrality today.

First, while there is no longer a direct relation between centrality and geographic entities such as the downtown, the CBD remains a key form of centrality. But the CBD in major international business centers is one profoundly reconfigured by technological and economic change. ...

Second, the center can extend into a metropolitan area in the form of a grid of nodes of intense business activity. ... Insofar as these various nodes are articulated through cyberroutes or digital highways, they form a grid that is a geographic correlate of the most advanced type of "center." The places that fall outside this new grid of digital highways, however, are peripheralized. This grid of nodes represents, in my analysis a reconstitution of the concept of region. Far from neutralizing geography, the grid is likely to be embedded in conventional forms of transport infrastructure, notably rapid rail and highways connecting to airports. ...
(Compare this to the Silicon Valley notion that the diameter of the cluster is defined by a 2-hour drive.)

Third, we are seeing the formation of a transterritorial "center" constituted via telematics and intense economic transactions. It consists of the multiple and diversifying inter-city links that take place partly in electronic markets and transactions and partly through the intensifying circulation of goods, information, firms, and workers. In this regard this is both a territorialized and deterritorialized space of centrality. It requires both a specific logic for territorial development and the infrastructure for global networking technologies.

The relationship of cities within this last transterritorial center sounds much like that of organizations within a conventional agglomeration economy.

The global integration of markets make many ... activities redundant and makes collaboration a far more complex matter, one that has the effect of sharpening the division of labor within the network. Beyond the necessary range of specialized services present in all these centers, we now also see a trend toward the formation of specialized capabilities that partially differentiate centers and simultaneously integrate them into a larger global network. This configuration also promotes the formation of strategic alliances. ...

In my reading the globally integrated financial system is not only about competition among countries as is typically assumed. The trend is toward an increase in specialized collaborative efforts among these centers. Further, insofar as markets are integrated, growth overall is maximized through growth in all centers.


But why have financial centers at all? It comes back to well-known arguments about social networks and interpretation vs/ information.

The continuing weight of major centers is, in a way, countersensical, as is, for that matter, the existence of an expanding network of financial centers. The rapid development of electronic exchanges the growing digitization of much financial activity, and the fact that finance produces a dematerialized and hypermobile product, all suggest that location should not matter.

3 reasons that explain the trend toward consolidation in a few centers rather than massive dispersal:

a) The importance of social connectivity and central functions.
First, while ICTs do indeed enable geographic dispersal of economic activities without losing system integration, they have also had the effect of strengthening the importance of central coordination and control functions for firms and even for markets. ...
One fact that has become increasingly evident is that to maximize the benefits of ICTs firms need not only the infrastructure but a complex mix of other resources. Most of the value added that these technologies can produce for advanced service firms lies in so-called externalities - material and human resources such as state-of-the-art office buildings, top talent, and the social networking infrastructure that maximizes connectivity. ...
A second fact that is emerging with greater clarity concerns the nature of "information." There are two types of information. One is the datum, which may be complex yet is standard knowledge: the level at which a stock market closes, a privatization of a public utility, the bankruptcy of a bank. But there is a far more difficult type of "information," akin to and interpretation/evaluation/judgment. ... Access to the first kind of information is now global and immediate ... But the second type of information requires a complicated mixture of elements, which we could think of as the social infrastructure for global connectivity. It is these specialized kinds of social connectivity that give major financial centers a leading edge. ...

b) Cross-border mergers and alliances.
Global firms in the financial industry need enormous resources, which is leading to rapid mergers and acquisitions of firms and strategic alliances among markets in different countries. ...
I would argue that another kind of "merger" is the consolidation of electronic networks that connect a very select number of markets. In the late 1990s several financial exchanges sought to form highly integrated alliances. ...
What we are seeing now is a ... pattern whereby the cooperation or division of functions is somewhat institutionalized: strategic alliances not only between firms across borders but also between markets. There is competition, strategic collaboration, and hierarchy.

c)Denationalized elites and agendas. ...
Major international business centers produce what we can think of as a new subculture, a move from the "national" version of international activities to the "global" version. ... I would posit that major cities, and the variety of so-called global business meetings (such as those of the World Economic Forum in Davos and other similar occasions), contribute to denationalize corporate elites.


Essentially: The global economy and the people that are more part of it than of their national/regional economies still need a place or home. Global cities provide it.


Some numbers on the global economy:
By 1999 companies had well over half a million affiliates outside their home countries accounting for U.S. $11 trillion in sales, a very significant figure if we consider that global trade stood at U.S. $8 trillion.
The orders of magnitude of cross-border financial transactions have risen sharply, as illustrated by the 1999 U.S. $68 trillion in the value of internationally traded derivatives, a major component of the global economy.

Saturday

Cities as drivers of innovation and economic growth

The economy of cities, Jane Jacobs, 1969

Jane Jacobs sees cities as fundamentally different from other economic regions - not as larger and more complicated villages. In her book, she describes an anthropological view of the earliest cities as centers of trade between non-agricultural tribes that develop sophisticated agricultural techniques as they grow. This conflicts with the view traditionally held at the time that hunter/gatherer villages developed agriculture and subsequently grew to become cities.

Jacobs perspective allows a new analysis of cities and their interactions with the rural areas around them. Since she focuses on cities' imports and exports, her's could be seen as simply an input-output model that treats the city (ie. agglomeration economy) as black box. However, the anthropological background she provides and her analysis of divisions of labor within the city go a long way towards opening the black box and understanding it. Her description of entrepreneurship and incremental innovation makes intuitive sense: People doing their job, naturally find ways to improve on certain aspects - mainly through trial and error. If they get positive feedback, they may shift their focus from the original work to elaborating the improvements. One of Jacobs' examples is Mrs. Rosenthal, a New York seamstress. Mrs. Rosenthal was unhappy with the way her dresses fit her customers, so she used her sewing and fitting skills to create bras. She was so successful with this improvement that she went on to give up on sewing dresses and founded Maidenform instead. One of the most important factors in this example is that Mrs. Rosenthal was originally engaged in local work, which she adapted. Maidenform, by contrast became an export business (ie., exporting out of the city of New York). Once the new line of business was firmly established, factories could be set up in rural areas to save costs and improve efficiency. This example is representative of Jacobs's description of the city as a self-reciprocating, open system.

Jacobs emphasizes that this kind of innovation can only happen in cities where there is a high density of people and jobs as well and if a high degree of specialization can be supported by the economy. Since established businesses are constantly being moved to rural areas, the city must create new sources of income, ie. new exports. To achieve this, a vibrant local economy is necessary to serve as the basis for innovation. The inefficiency of cities is an advantage for the trial and error process of incremental innovation: a large variety of different kinds of work is happening in one place, which encourages new combinations; the sustainability of high degrees of specialization lets innovations succeed before they are fully developed, and replication of work means that many instances of trial and error can occur in tandem.

While individual specialization is important, according to Jacobs, cities should not specialize. They need to maintain many different avenues of innovation/trial and error because only a fraction will succeed. Efficiency works against innovation in this case. Some of the most important specializations/innovations that cities provide have been the generic ones that allow new businesses of all kinds to form: venture capitalists, lawyers, printers, leasing of factory equipment, agencies to provide temporary workers, etc.

Even though Jacobs doesn't touch on radical high-tech innovations or consumer-driven innovation (cf. von Hippel's work), she provides a very tangible, practical account of how agglomeration economies work. Her model gives many insights into what it takes to create an agglomeration economy or to revive a stagnating city.

An interview with Jane Jacobs.